Thanks to everyone who has added their thoughts on why they unsubscribe from a blog’s RSS feed. There have been 109 comments left on that post so far and some interesting recurring themes have emerged.
I’ve attempted to categorize them below. Obviously with 103 opinions (and most people giving multiple reasons all in their own words) I’ve had to make some judgement calls in classifying comments left. Some of the categories below have overlap but I think you’ll get a pretty good picture of what motivates people to unsubscribe from RSS feeds.
34 Reasons Why People Unsubscribe from RSS feeds:
- Too many posts (the post levels are too overwhelming) – 37
- Infrequent Posting (or the blog is effectively dead) – 29
- Partial Excerpts Feeds – 25
- Blog Changes Focus (too much off topic posting) – 23
- Too many posts that I see elsewhere (Redundant, Repeated or Recycled News) – 19
- Uninteresting Content – 16
- Irrelevant Content – 13
- The Blogger’s Ego – Too much self promotion – 11
- Low Quality Content – 11
- Too many posts that are too long – 10
- Negative blogging – 7
- Feed Errors – Especially when a Feed Reloads the latest 10-20 posts every time – 7
- Offensive Content/Personal attacks/Discrimination – 6
- ‘infomercials’ (too much selling) – 6
- Blog Titles that Don’t Tell what the post is about – 5
- No or Poor Formatting in posts – 5
- My own interests as a reader change – 5
- No Longer Useful or Valuable – 4
- Too many links in the text and not enough content – 4
- Advertising – 3
- Inconsistent writing (style and focus) – 2
- Too Many Grammatical Errors – 2
- Found other feeds that are better – 2
- Too Narrow a focus – 1
- Too much repetition in topic – 1
- Pushiness of Blogger – 1
- Blogger Doesn’t Respond to Comments – 1
- No Images in the feed – 1
- Lack of Confidence or Opinion – 1
- Lack of a sense of who the blogger is – 1
- Too much clutter/extras at the end of posts – 1
- Talking Down to Readers – 1
- Too many quotes – 1
- Change of Primary blogger – 1
A few brief comments (I wouldn’t want to have a long post now….):
The Frequency of Posting is obviously a big factor with 35% of respondents saying that too many posts was reason for unsubscribing and 28% saying that infrequent posts was reason to delete a feed from their reader. Interestingly, the ‘infrequent posting’ vote was perhaps a little less than last time I asked a group of bloggers this question. I suspect that with advancements in Feed Readers that inactive feeds don’t bother as many people as they did previously (ie Google Reader has a mode where you simply don’t see a feed unless it’s updated).
The Partial Feeds Vote got off to a slow start but gained momentum as the comment thread grew. 24% of respondents said they unsubscribe from feeds that are partial or just title feeds.
Off Topic Posting and blogs changing direction/focus is an obvious annoyance to many (this one surprised me slightly) with 22% of people giving it as a reason.
Content – I found it interesting that the quality, relevance and nature of content came down the list. Things like the form and frequency of the feed dominated the discussion while the actual content itself came in as secondary importance. Perhaps this was skewed slightly by the way I asked the question and by the first responses (I suspect that some people were swayed by the issues that others already raised).
Number one is really interesting
I can understand the top two, however, finding that sweet spot can be tough. I’ve unsubscribed because of too many posts to keep up with, but I never have because of infrequent posting. The third one doesn’t bother me, as part of the reason I subscribe is to know when the site is updated. Generally, I still visit the actual site. If I’m not interested in going to the site to finish reading, the site probably isn’t that great anyway.
Seem like the ‘golden middle’ rule applies here. It’s a thin line between short and long posts. Do you know where’s the middle Darren?
It seems odd at first that too many posts can turn off readers, after all, “content is king”. However, I find I’m much more likely to unsubscribe from a blog with too many posts than one with too few.
I think there are two reasons: 1) Reading blogs can take a lot of time, and you almost feel obliged to read every single article posted and 2) Posting quality can suffer if it’s too often.
Kind of tough to find that happy medium of not too many,not too few posts, huh? LOL
Still recovering from death and illness here. I have a day home so I am trying to say hello to my Internet friends! Hope all is well with you and you have a wonderful day!
dont be on both extremes (“too much” and “infrequent” posts).
[…] Repeated or Recycled News) – 19 siehe Details: 34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog Trackback-URL Gelesen: 1 heute:1 […]
I never expected too many posts to even be on the list, not to talk about being #1..
I guess it’s about the tool you’re using, according to the latest statistics more and more people are using Google Reader, which in a first view shows you all the new posts from your subscribed sites, I guess that if 2 blogs have posted 4 times a day, it gets a bit overwhelming and messy for the reader.
I use Firefox Live Bookmarks so I’m not really affected by this.
Another good reason to relax and post less, but with value.
Allen.H
How about 35 – after careful review you noticed that the author is an idiot. Like a real, true-to-life idiot. I’ve subscribed to blogs and after a while I’d think “hmm, this guy really is off his rocker”.
Bob Hasko
http://www.TeesMyBody.com T-Shirts
[…] Aqui ficam 34 razões que levam os leitores a cancelarem a subscrição de feeds de um blog (em inglês). […]
I liked a lot this list, and I think in my case the first one might matter a lot lol lots of posts can be very troublesome.
Great job in here, very useful articles. Thank you
Who would have thought that too many posts was a problem. I suppose that is too many low quality posts in particular… The fastest blog i subscribe to is techcrunch which seems to put out 4-10 posts a day, i quite enjoy knowing there is always something new to read… keeps me distracted from my real work :-)
Thanks for compiling the list Darren. I read through all the comments yesterday and got the general sense of people’s likes and dislikes, but the list here makes it so much easier to understand what turns off readers.
I’d like to see a ‘why readers subscribe to a feed’ post since I think that will prove just as valuable.
A couple of thoughts about a list like this. One is to note that while some people will unsubscribe if you publish too often. others will unsubscribe if you don’t publish often enough. Based on the comments from yesterday I think it would be easy enough to find a happy medium, but my point is that you can’t please everyone and if you try you may end up with a blog that offends no one, but also pleases no one.
I also think that a quality blog can overcome most all of the complaints. If we were to take a look at a variety of A-list bloggers I’d guess many do some of the things on the list yet still have a large audience. For example Aaron Wall only publishes partial feeds, but the blog is so good that many people will happily click through to the site to read it. I know I will.
The most important thing for any blog will always be the quality of the blog itself.
Thanks again for the list.
Very interesting compilation. Of course, the #1 issue (posting too often) is a clear advantage when it comes to building deep archives, so you have to take the bad with the good, I guess.
Nice Darren, I’ll graphically chart them and credit it back to ure site :)
Well I have to say I didn’t expect too many posts to be the number one reason! It does make sense if you think about it, but I just would have expected something like uninteresting content, or low quality content to have been up there.
I guess now it’s just a case of finding out what your optimum number of posts per day/week is…..
[…] Darren put a an entry asking why makes you unsubscribe from feed reading and the response went overwhelmed. Here are the result collected from Darren’s compilation (of readers comments). A reference you might need if you noticed a reducing in your feed readers. Others in chart consists of the following: […]
[…] Via Problogger, leo un interesante artículo en el que mediante 103 opiones, recogen 34 razones por las que la gente elimina feeds de los lectores. […]
[…] Via Problogger, leo un interesante artículo en el que mediante 103 opiones, recogen 34 razones por las que la gente elimina feeds de los lectores. […]
[…] Update: Darren was nice enough to sort through the comments and posted what he found in 34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog. You may still want to read through the comments in the original post as they offer more details about why each of the 34 things listed might cause someone to unsubscribe. […]
I had always thought that too many posts – just like not enough posts might kill a blog. Got to find a good balance between quality and quantity.
Wow, what an interesting list!!
I too, am wondering where that “Golden Middle” is for posting! I have at least one post per day – sometimes two, and rarely three….
To few? Any more would seem like too much!
I am surprised that more people didn’t say bad grammar or low quality posts.
#35: Lists that are longer than 10 items.
Please unsubscribe me.
Number one really surprised me since many of the big blogs have a ton of posts every day. But I can see how it can frustrate people, there are a few big blogs that I check out only a few times a week and hate the fact that there may be 3 or 4 pages of posts that I need to go through if I want to see everything that was posted since I last visited. I usually leave after the first page or two though…
Generally speaking I won’t unsubscribe unless it is obvious that the blog has died. But we should remember that most bloggers go through a lull period where things like writer’s block, burnout, bad health or the real world can get in the way of our blogging. I believe in cutting people some slack and giving them the benefit of the doubt.
Some folks probably start pruning their list simply because it is getting too large or unwieldy. I subscribe to literally thousands of blogs and if you use a filter like I do that is built into most good newsreaders (like GreatNews for example), then it’s really not necessary to prune the list so often. After all, subscribing to a feed costs nothing and we have everything to gain.
I’m still thinking about the first one. One of my favorite blogs is Lifehacker and they post several times a day. With the main writer Gina posting several times herself. Wired magazine even mentioned the fact that she did this.
I also subscribe to the Huffington Post which is always full in my Bloglines inbox. I certainly wont delete Huffington Post, but I wont READ everything they write either.
I unsubscribe only when the writer is has lost their edge or is changing the point of their blog.
But too many posts? I don’t get that one.
[…] Anyway, if you’re still reading here Darren has 34 reasons why readers unsubscribe. Damn, reading that list II’ve done all 34. Hmmm. Filed under: Blog Tips @ 10:21 pm# […]
Too many posts on the top of the list ?! i thought people likes authors to update their blog regularly ?
I don’t believe any of these reasons. I do all 34 things and I have more than 100,000 subscribers, according to WordPress.
Oh, and I’ve had several CEOs tell me they love my link blog and I posted 98 things to that so far today (and 1,800 in the past month).
Translation: do what you love, put stuff up you’d love to read, and the rest will fall into place.
Oh, and I’ve learned over and over again that people who say they are unsubscribing never do. It’s just a threat to try to make you feel bad.
[…] Darren Rowse compiled a list of reasons why readers unsubscribe from your blogs. […]
I never knew that too many posts per day would kill my readership. I always used to consider that more posts = more readers. Maybe you should ask your readers “What is the optimum number of posts per day”
Is your readership mostly people-who-blog, as opposed to people-who-only-read-blogs?
Since this is an RSS-focused thing, I’m curious about what reasons more general users (read: don’t know/don’t use RSS) would give for not reading a blog.
We blogger-types tend to be have sometimes unrealistic and higher than normal standards when it comes to what we want. (Full vs. Partial feeds is a religious issue with us, and that’s kinda amusing and sad. It’s like serious throwdown time when that conversation starts. Doesn’t that strike anyone as odd, regardless of position on this issue?)
10 Gründe, warum Blog-Leser “Good-Bye” sagen…
Warum sagen Leser einem Blog Good-Bye? Am einfachsten erfähren wir die Gründe, wenn wir eben die Leser fragen. ProBlogger Darren Rowse hat dies in seinem Blog getan. Lest die 10 wichtigsten Gründe für einen Abschied als Anreiz zum …
Wow, I was blown off by Point #1 too. And to think it tops the list! Another surprise.
This makes me wonder if it could be the setting of the feed. If it has been set to notiffy the subscribers of every new post, then it could get a little threatening to get 2 or 3 emails from a blogger per day.
I used to think too that more posts = more readers like Thilak.
Or maybe now is more interesting and quality posts = more readers? So if you keep posting things that don’t interest or benefit readers they’ll choose to walk away.
Looks like bloggers have bigger shoes to fill now ;)
I was actually planning to make 50 posts a day by recruiting paid bloggers for my blog. But it seems it will only brought negative effect to my feed subs as it’s on the point 1…. :-(
[…] นี่คือ รายงานจำนวน feed ปัจจุบันของผมจาก google trend หลังจากที่ได้ unsubscribe feed หลายๆอัน ที่มันโอเวอร์มากๆอย่าง gizmodo engadget ออกไป ทำให้จำนวนโพส ที่ต้องอ่านต่อวันลดลง และลดจำนวน feed กลับมาเหลือต่ำกว่า 300 ได้อีกครั้งโดยวิธีคัดเลือก feed พวกนี้ออกก็ได้มาจากเรื่อง 34 Reasons Why People Unsubscribe from RSS feeds ของ problogger โดยเอาข้อแรกๆมาใช้เช่น […]
Don’t forget this is reasons for unsubscribing, not reasons for choosing-not-to-subscribe-in-the-first-place.
The difference? If I wander onto a new blog and see outstandingly interesting content, I’ll subscribe. It has to be outstandingly interesting, cos I come across several new blogs every day but if my feed is going to stay manageable, I can’t subscribe to more than one new one every few weeks. (And prune unwanted ones every few months).
If the content isn’t extremely interesting, I won’t subscribe in the first place. So you won’t see me leave. That’s why content-related reasons are relatively low on the list.
Here’s something that’s happened to me a few times: I subscribe to a techie blog, but find that many of the posts are entirely personal. (I just unsubscribed to a Drupal blog cos of unending photos of the blogger’s new baby!) What can the blogger do about this, apart from keeping two separate blogs? 1. Use categories properly, and 2. Offer two distinct feeds. Don’t offer a combined feed as well; it just causes confusion.
[…] Ich habe in meinen Feeds mehrmals vom Artikel “34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog” gelesen und habs mir auch gleich angeschaut! Nur zum übersetzen kam ich noch nicht und bin froh das Jörg Petermann schon einen Teil übernommen hat… Sind zwar nur die ersten 10 Gründe warum Leser ihr Feedabo kündigen aber das sollte für die meisten reichen da sie schon mit diesen ihre Probleme haben! […]
Hi Darren,
Great post.
A sequel – “why people do and don’t comment on blogs” might also be interesting.
A better question might be “What Motivates you to Subscribe to a Blog’s Newsfeed?“
[…] 34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog […]
I think there is still a lot of room for discussion regarding the first reason, that is too many posts.
Despite people mentioning it is there empirical evidence out there that too many posts will reduce your audience? Obviously “too many” is relative for each blog and its topic, still.
How very valuable to make that list! Hopefully the people who offered their comments [mine included] can absorb their own advice when it comes to blogging.
I think the breakin’-it-down-Barney-style rule of thumb for any Blogger [Article writer] would be to ask the question, “If I wasn’t me, would I stick around for this?”
Thanks for your value.
Samsara
Robert – I partly agree with you. Compelling content will keep people subscribed despite most of the problems that you could have – although as someone who has unsubscribed to blogs from time to time I’d say that some of the above (for me tis more about the content relevancy and quality as well as blogger ego) that gets me deleting a feed.
[…] Dieser Frage ging Darren Rowse in seinem Posting “34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog” nach. Zu diesem Zweck hat er Kommentare zu einer entsprechenden Frag ausgewertet. […]
I was surprised that intrusive ads or distracting ads was not much higher in the survey.
I am getting to the point where if I see an adsense ad on a site I immediately question the quality or veracity of the content.
Your site by the way is an exception to the rule. I appreciate the vast and expert information you freely offer your readers.
Thanks,
Antonio
[…] V�itin taannoin, ett� otsikot eiv�t ole t�rkeit� bloggaajille. ProBloggerin merkint� 34 syyt�, joiden takia blogin lukeminen loppuu antaa ep�suoraa tukea v�itteelleni. […]
[…] 34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog […]
[…] – MindValley Labs has an interesting post on how to make money from youtube videos. – Darren Rowse has a post on 34 Reasons Why Readers Unsubscribe from Your Blog – Zazz Post Ticker, a great plugin to display recent posts with a stylish JavaScript fading effect (see at the top for example). – MyUnistaller, an alternative program to default Windows Add/Remove Programs – MyBlogLog and quest for building community – The Complete WordPress.com Video Guide and Tutorial […]